Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I switched from the iphone to android and I agree with your assessment. Android's UX is good, iPhone's is great.

I have high hopes for Android 3.0 (Gingerbread, due in Q4) which is allegedly going to be a major UI revamp.

In the mean time I'll enjoy my flash, portable hotspot, tethering and non-ATT carrier :)



I'm always suspicious of "I switched from Brand X to Brand Y and Brand X was better for reasons I can't fully articulate as they are almost subconcious". It seems obvious that people moving from one thing to another are going to be affected by small differences that someone coming to it fresh wouldn't be bothered by.

The fact that everyone knows Apple has better UI only adds to this, but you can find the same thing in a thousand different Windows to Mac, Windows to Linux, Gnome to KDE or vice versa stories. Some people will get quite irate about how crappy the new UI is, even (somewhat tellingly) if it's a Mac or iPhone that they're moving to after becoming accustomed to something else.


I'll quantify it for you. It takes me more clicks and presses to do the same things on android vs iphone.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: